Roles & application to be a review

Role of Reviewers

  • Provide an informed, expert judgment on the merits of a paper in the form of written comments suitable for transmission to the authors.
  • Decide whether the paper represent a genuine, useful advance in methodology, understanding, and/or novel data analysis.
  • Send a separate letter or report for the Associate Editor (not to be seen by authors) recommending rejection or publication, either in its current form or after revision is made.